Trade information

Reverted

Information
Start of negotiation	2022-11-24- 13:18
End of negotiation	2022-11-24- 13:19
Restrictions' level	10

Hong Kong Monarch

Tang Ting Nip
Salary:	-
Contract:	School talent	Age:	15 y.
RT:	48	Height:	198 cm.
Potential:	8

Magnificent Maniacs

Vidmantas Parna
Salary:	22423 Eu
Contract:	1 S	Age:	25 y.
RT:	421	Height:	212 cm.
Potential:	5

1.1 1.1 HK Monarch

Trade/Lending players: HK Monarch & Maniacs

-- 90 S 25 d.

Team made a trade offer

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Player: Tang Ting Nip

Started to play in a new team after a trade -- 90 S 25 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Player: Vidmantas Parna

Started to play in a new team after a trade -- 90 S 25 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

1.1 1.1 Maniacs

Trade offer accepted -- 90 S 25 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

1.1 2.1 fourkings

Press message hidden by federation volunteer or administrator -- 90 S 29 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Fair play committee

Trade has been reverted by the "Fair play" committee -- 90 S 29 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Fair play committee

The Fair play committee decided that the trade is unfair and teams are given a warning. -- 90 S 29 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Fair play committee

How the Fair Play Committee members voted:
- volunteers voted "Revert and punish": 0
- volunteers voted "Revert": 10
- volunteers voted "Fair": 1

These reasons were chosen by the volunteers during voting:
7 - Salary drop (one or more useful players are exchanged for useless player(s) with the only goal to reduce salaries)
3 - Suspicion that trade’s goal is to help one of the teams

-- 90 S 29 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

3.4 2.2 dwyane3

As FPC members may not comment the decisions made, I would like to share the reasoning behind the decision made.

Maniacs gave away a top class 421 RT defender at discounted salary which is helpful to Monarch, and got a 315 peak RT youth in return that is unlikely to reach WL1 level. The fact that Maniacs also save 22.000 weekly salary makes this trade unfair by the FPC vote.

We would like to encourage the teams making the trades that may look suspicious to describe the reasoning of the trade when making it. By providing more information about the trade to FPC will help the committee to make a better informed decision. In addition, we are encouraging FPC to have a discussion prior making the vote so the decision made is well-discussed. -- 90 S 31 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Show hidden replies: 8

1.1 1.1 CoachM0329

Thank you for your fruitful explanation. -- 90 S 31 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

2.2 3.1 benislovas

As far as I see, you are not a member of FPC. Could I ask, how did you come to this conclusion? Asked all the members about their reasoning? -- 90 S 31 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

3.4 2.2 dwyane3

benislovas I participate in FPC Discord channel where we discussed the current issues arising and we are looking how to make FPC work better. We are creating a structure for decision-making, and we will share more information about that with the community. -- 90 S 31 d.

-- (Translate) (Translate EN)

Trade information

Reverted

Hong Kong Monarch

Magnificent Maniacs

Restrictions' level

Calculations

Trades' rules for this restriction level

Quickguide

Report this post