Informação da troca

Aceito

Informação
Começo da negociação	2019-08-01- 00:00
Fim da negociação	2019-08-01- 00:01
Nível de restrições	9

NW Shockwave

	Jovanni Merden
	Salário:	12878 Eu
	Contrato:	1 T	Idade:	26 a.
	HT:	283	Altura:	198 cm
	Potencial:	10
	Virgil Haungs
	Salário:	18513 Eu
	Contrato:	5 T	Idade:	25 a.
	HT:	262	Altura:	208 cm
	Potencial:	9
	Edward Blacknall
	Salário:	-
	Contrato:	Categ de base	Idade:	17 a.
	HT:	82	Altura:	202 cm
	Potencial:	8

Kamer Pirates

	Arimantas Balanda
	Salário:	18284 Eu
	Contrato:	2 T	Idade:	30 a.
	HT:	289	Altura:	189 cm
	Potencial:	3
	John Wick
	Salário:	-
	Contrato:	Categ de base	Idade:	16 a.
	HT:	74	Altura:	200 cm
	Potencial:	10
	Russell Jarman
	Salário:	-
	Contrato:	Categ de base	Idade:	16 a.
	HT:	73	Altura:	176 cm
	Potencial:	9

Troca/Emprestando jogadores: Shockwave & KR Pirates

-- 71 T 11 d.

Equipe fez uma oferta de troca

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador:

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador: Virgil Haungs

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador:

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador:

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador: John Wick

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Jogador:

Começou a jogar em um novo time após uma troca -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

Oferta de troca aceita -- 71 T 11 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

2.2 4.4 Frankebasta

Once again, TheCoach is using his clout over the USA community to circumvent the rules about Trades.

I didn't report the trade involving this Balanda guy because, on its face value it was borderline acceptable.

But after one week, as soon as the "grace period" ended, theCoach unveils its plan: Balanda is not of any use. Fired.
(same happens for the other team: Haungs is up for trade, see Press Conference)

all of the above constitutes a VIOLATION of the following rule: Veterans should not be traded for prospects ONLY.
By the act of releasing Balanda, theCoach effectively traded 2 veterans for 2 prospects!

Excerpt from the Official Rules of the Game:

Trades' rules that must be followed and respected by all users:

2) Players' trade somehow has to benefit both teams (financially, in respect of team composition, etc).
You can trade a good but expensive player to a bit worse but cheaper player. You should not overuse this type of trade. -- 71 T 18 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+2

1.1 1.1 HeyHoudini

I see word "lending" not word "trade"

https://prnt.sc/oq5sr8 -- 71 T 18 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+4

:D. Looks like someone didn’t take their meds again...... -- 71 T 18 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+4

2.2 4.4 Frankebasta

Whatever
My complaint is about TheCoach action to fire a player.
That's a fact -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+1

Comitê de Fair Play

Esta troca foi reportada como injusta. No entanto, o comitê de Fair play decidiu que essa troca é justa. -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+0

2.2 4.4 Frankebasta

Pirates gave up a pot9 and one pot10 prospects and their best rated player in exchange for a pot8 prospect and two lesser players. One of which the Pirates is trying to unload (either because they cannot afford the salary or whatever reason).
Which means that the Pirates traded two prospects in exchange of one, only to gain 9cm difference between Balanda and Merden!
And you mean to tell me this is a Fair trade?
Just look at the numbers!
Just look at the rule!
As I copy/pasted above, a trade as such is against the rules! -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+2

I think you are not looking at the rules correctly. The trade as such is not against the rules. That being said I think the Pirates made a bad deal for their team here, giving up two own-scouted players that have Wl1 potential for two players that are rather expensive for a WL4 team. But it's nowhere against the rules to trade useful Veterans for young high pots. -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+4

Mostrar respostas ocultas: 14

想要给一个人脱罪，那么你有1000条理由，这个游戏没有规则，交易合不合理，只不过少数人说了算而已， -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+3

If I was in FTC I would have voted down the trade....but I am not and so I trust their judgement. Simply put, if you have a problem with the way FTC is being run then become a member yourself and change it.....all of this complaining in the press conferences is just nonsense -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+1

FTC sees more of the trade than us, as a 3rd party do....so either trust them or become a member yourself and decide how a trade should go. -- 71 T 19 d.

-- (Traduzir) (Traduzir EN)

+1