Im ok with giving two average players (one is old with bad skills and no xp, the other one could be better trained) for one old guy to help me get as high as possible, a move which would cost me a lot more money... I offered you 10 trades before this one would have said the same with the others ? .. and I even liked this trade, but if commitee believes it's not fair, why I should be punished ? All in all, the trade canceling hurt me too my.chances to fight for promotion, I was thinking on sending my young players to youth team with the space created and hiring one more good old man. Now the chance is gone too-- 06-09
This deal would set a bad precedent case for future cases. Trading two players with perspective (9 and 10pot) and good contracts for one old player on a 1 season contract is clearly unbalanced. Not by extremely much, but the offer was lopsided as it was. Not reverting a trade like this would set a problematic precedent case where other teams would trade very good young talents for an old player on a 1S contract. Feishe himself fired the player after the trade was reverted so this tells me quite a bit about his value for him.
As to the motive of reaching Top16, this is not really for us to judge. We can sanction cases like this if this should happen regularly in the future, but assuming it now would be overreaching. Considering the player Funes traded for would have only had value for 2 or 3 games at all would, by the way, have been an even more outrageous idea considering what he put on the table for it.
In the committee we stated more than once publicly that you can always ask us before offering/accepting a trade and we will answer in a very short time frame if we think the deal is unproblematic. Also, there is always the possibility - even after a reverted trade - to adjust the offer and make the trade happen still.-- 06-10
Komanda you're right, but have you ever thought that if you cancel the deal like this, Funes will benefit the most. Not only did he use the deal to achieve the goal of the top 16, but after that, all the young players will return to the team. You will make him very happy, so I'm disappointed with the fpc. You're terrible.-- 06-10
Ariel, you mentioned the word difficult, why is difficult, because you all know the transaction there is no cheating, so you give me the explanation is to prevent cheating, I do not accept, do you know the purpose of the deal, he is a legitimate transaction, you just cancel the transaction for some political reasons, and as a team manager, what did I do wrong, but I received a good deal to the team, as the two sides of the deal, why funes obtained huge profits, and all the loss to be assumed let me a person, this is obviously unfair,-- 06-10
I´m not the person to answer that question, but what i do know is that Razeev (and probably all the FPC) works to make this game better, I have had a polemic trade cancelled by the FPC previously season, I remember feeling upset and harmed, but I have the chance to talk to some members of the FPC and I saw the other side of the story, they make mistakes of course, it would be important to define and adjust the FPC rol in the future and to guarantee at least some experience in their members, but for me is definitely a significant improve as it was before FPC exists.-- 06-10
If certain communities would work harder to act against cheating behavior (like farm teams that serve the purpose of aquiriing players fir the main team) we as the FTC would be able to be a little less strict in looking at trades. As it is however there is quite some cheating behavior in some communities (which we are already working hard against), so we have to act more strictly.-- 06-10
As a member of FPC, if you cannot treat every transaction fairly and fairly, then you cannot do this job well, which is why you cannot cancel players' trust. I am sorry for your reply, you hurt all Chinese people.-- 06-11
Razeev I didn't misunderstand you, you speak, has been fully expressed, you'll be players of different regions have different law enforcement standard, for some area to get very loose tube, and some area is very severe, this fully shows that law enforcement unfair to you, you have a very serious racial discrimination, I hope you can take the initiative to quit the FPC, because we need some fair FPC, you have not such a person, you have a very serious racial discrimination, you has different standard law enforcement. Of course I will continue to move forward, I will not be entangled in this trade, and lose the continued strength of the team, I will be more and more strong.-- 06-11
TheCoach I don't know if you are aware of the role of the fair alliance. When I click on the fair alliance, the first sentence I see is this: the fair competition commission is made up of enthusiastic volunteers from different countries. The main purpose of this committee is to maintain the fairness of the game, then razeev very clearly expressed his will according to different areas use different law enforcement standards to determine whether the trade fair, could you tell me how to to such a person to maintain the fairness of the game, I want to ask what do you think of this matter, I also want to ask razeev why want to use different standards to law enforcement, why can't we treat every trade fair, this has nothing to do and which district, each transaction should be independent, I hope more people can participate in discussing the question, after this happened, a member of the FPC apologized to me, That he made a bad vote to cancel my deal, which is great, but he's not razeev, and I want razeev to come out, and I want him to come out as a man, and everybody should be held accountable for what he said, what he did, and not hiding like a bitch.-- 06-12
I do wonder what you are referring to, feishe. In no comment did I say that we use different standards for different trades. Where do you read that? It seems that either you misunderstood what I wrote or you WANT to misunderstand what I wrote. What I did say is that there is cheating behavior we have uncovered and keep uncovering (in several different communities), and to avoid this behavior now and in the future we have to be strict with trades IN GENERAL. This is all I said. So why do you want to read something else there? And why start insulting me as racist and as "hiding like a bitch"? Why are you so mad? Or afraid? Or what is it? Go ahead and tell me. I don't get it, except that I feel that you are purposely insulting and trolling me.-- 06-12
Can you stand up again, this is very good man, funes use trade stand on the stage of the 16, and then with the help of you, to take back his young players, funes without any loss of completed his transaction purposes, and I just received a good deal for the team, but loses to analyze 1045 credit points on the player's skills and potential, you must give me a way,-- 06-12
Feishe, I doubt anyone will be able to completely understand what you wrote, but I think I believe I understand what you are trying to state. Maybe if you understood the process it will help you.
1) two teams make a trade
2) trade is registered in community data base
3) some community member sees the trade that they do not like, and they can report it. This can be reported that day, or it could be 7 days from when the trade was done.
4) Members of the FPC get notification of the reported trade where they then discuss and make decisions. This could take 1-6 days.
So in your case, the reason why the trade was not reverted sooner is that it had a process to go through, some go through quick, some take time.
It is the risk/reward for trading.
Also, I concur with RaZeev was saying. Basically it is this: If every member did what was the "right" thing and we didn't have members the chose to make themselves and their communities (all communities) look bad, there would be no reason for a FPC. However that is not the case and their are many teams out there that have are cheating or have been cheating (35 teams closed this season for this behavior and in my opinion it should be close to 80), the FPC needs to look at trades in a careful manner that will make it difficult for cheaters to cheat.
Most here in the community are naive at the amount of cheaters nor have the comprehension to understand how it is getting done, so they often reach out and complain about the FPC, likely due to being naive, new, gullible, or they only care about themselves and do not see the big picture.
In the end, one person does not revert a trade or allow a trade, it is a group of members, Shanire included (Kick Ash was there as well until questionable behavior had been reported).
None of us in the FPC agree with every decision that has been made. You can either deal with your emotions about the FPC, or you can just move along and quit the game. The FPC is not going anywhere Feishe.
I will not back down, I will not actively close my account, you can close my account, before you close my account, I will continue to push out this transaction, until you can have a cancellation of the transaction after the work.-- 06-12
What are your plans Feishe? To make a big deal in the press conferences :D :D You think that will make something?
Fine Feishe you have three options
1) keep typing and likely end up getting banned
2) quit the game itself
3) accept the response given and take it all in, try not to create a false narrative of the facts and try not to assume things that you don't know the facts but try to speak as if you do.-- 06-12
There is nothing to back down to, because there is nothing to stand up to.
It appears that maybe you are just trying to stir things up, stating lies and false narratives twisting the truth what we call gas lighting. Are you trying to get others to try to complain too? It won't do anything.
Try to see the big picture, try not making everything about you.-- 06-12
Well, let's go back to the trading, funes in order to more powerful in the premiership, so he is going to make a change, he chose to use young players in exchange for help his players, in this deal he got really want, but I just accepted a favorable offer to the team, this is a win-win, you give me the initial explanation is that prevent cheating, so do you, in the purpose of the transaction between the parties, who cheated,-- 06-12
Thecoach you don't want to come back it doesn't matter, so we'll leave the trade in the news section and let all players see how you work, see how FPC is if a win-win deal is withdrawn, for me, one or two young players don't matter, I don't care,-- 06-12
Ikonėlės po žaidėjo vardu ir kitose skiltyse pateikia papildomą informaciją apie žaidėją.
- Forma: Nepasirengęs
- Forma: Beveik nepasirengęs
- Forma: Puiki
- Forma: Pavargęs
- Forma: Visiškai išsekęs
- Negali būti registruojamas rungtynėms
- Vardinis žaidėjas
- Komandos kapitonas
- Mokyklos talentas
- Žaidėjas baigęs karjerą
- Klubas nori išmainyti šį žaidėją
- Klubas nenori išmainyti šio žaidėjo
- Žaidėjo perkėlimas į kitas komandas šiuo metu negalimas
- Žaidėjas paskolintas (turi kontraktą su kitu klubu)
- Sezono pabaigoje ketina baigti karjerą
- Puikiai deda į krepšį
- Puikiai ginasi
- Puikiai pataiko tritaškius metimus
- Puikiai įžaidinėja kamuolį
Žaidėjo pasiekimai - kokius apdovanojimus ir kiek kartų yra gavęs.
- Aukso medalis
- Sidabro medalis
- Bronzos medalis
- Sezono MVP
- Sezono TOP5
- Perspektyviausias lygoje
- Žvaigždžių dienos dalyvis